Choosing the Best Health Plan

AS EMPLOYERS CONTINUE TO shift more of the financial burden to their employees, the cost of health care is projected to rise by 9% for the average worker from 2008 to 2009, according to benefits-consultant Hewitt Associates. If you're considering switching your health-insurance plan during open enrollment (which usually takes place in the fall), are starting a new job or are looking for insurance on your own, you'll want to compare how each plan stacks up. In addition to reviewing what will or won't be covered, you should have a sense of how much each option will cost you in out-of-pocket expenses.

The good news is that you're likely to have some choice over your plan. Approximately 30% of employers offer three medical plan options to their employees and another 28% of employers offer two options, according to 2007-2008 data from Hewitt Associates. Options include an HMO, a PPO (a preferred provider organization), a POS (point of service), an old-fashioned indemnity plan, and a traditional EPO (exclusive provider) plan. Our calculator can help you figure out which plan gives you the most bang for the buck. By entering the amount you paid in health-care costs last year and comparing it with the costs and reimbursement policies of the plans you're considering, you can see which plan makes the most sense — at least from your wallet's perspective.

But before you crunch the numbers, here are some tips on how to use this worksheet most effectively. First, if you're considering a PPO or POS plan — which provide a different reimbursement policy for doctors you see in-network vs. out — you should probably input the appropriate information for both situations in our calculator. (You can do so side-by-side, since our worksheet can handle two plans at once.) Typically, the way these policies work is that if you go to a doctor in-network, you'll pay a small dollar amount (known as a co-pay) somewhere in the vicinity of $20 per office visit. Should you go out-of-network, you'll be subject to coinsurance, which is usually 20% of the total bill after you've met the deductible.

You may also want to dig into your summary of benefits when estimating your health-care costs. This calculator assumes that the medical expenses you enter are reimbursable — and, unfortunately, that's not always the case. Physical therapy or mental-health sessions, for example, may be restricted to a certain number of visits annually. So make sure you read all the fine print before you make your final decision. Your actual out-of-pocket expenses could also be significantly greater than our calculator's estimation if the health plan rejects a claim or asks you to cover any amount above what the plan deems reasonable or customary.

And keep in mind that price isn't everything. When comparing an HMO with a PPO, the strict managed-care plan will always be more wallet-friendly. But often times you get what you pay for. So you may opt to spend a little more out of pocket for the freedom to see the doctor of your choice.

What Will That Health Plan Really Cost You?

Calculator - Compare Health Care Plan Costs -
Investor Alert

New York Markets Close in:

• Earnings Wall:
I complained online — and got back $1,200
I complained online and got $1,200 back Getty Images
5 ways to be a more effective complainer

A state-by-state map of foreclosure inventory
A state-by-state map of foreclosure inventory
The inventory of foreclosed homes dropped for the 32nd month in a row in June, but it's still high in some states.
2 new reverse-mortgage rules for couples

Twitter, treat your investors as well as Facebook does
Twitter needs to treat shareholders like Facebook does Getty Images
Deep Dive: Phil van Doorn explains why Twitter is going to have to ramp up its game considerably.
Twitter growth may hang on World Cup kick
Analysts rush to lift Twitter price targets

7 reasons I love my boss
7 reasons I love my boss Netflix
The ideal boss might be you.

How restaurants trick you into spending more
How menus trick you into spending more
Restaurant menus are carefully designed to encourage diners to spend more.

Parents, you’re paying for college in the wrong way
Parents, you're paying for college wrong AFP/Getty Images
When Junior’s college tuition bill comes, parents may want to rethink how they’re going to pay it.
3 pet medication scams and how to stop them

10 things winemakers
won’t tell you
10 things winemakers won't tell you AFP/Getty Images
What goes into your glass of Pinot? Food coloring, weird additives, and a 400% markup. MarketWatch explains the 10 secrets of the trade that winemakers won’t tell you.

Russell Brand slams Hannity over Gaza show
Russell Brand says Fox News host Sean Hannity acted like a terrorist in a recent "debate" on his show about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Obama-Netanyahu ‘transcript’ fuels uproar
Commentary: Gaza could be economic oasis
Need to know
Synchrony off to lackluster start in stock debut
Apple to cut 200 jobs at Beats
Valeant plunges on new-look outlook
EHealth shares plummet after broker report
10-year Treasury yield jumps to 3-week high
European banks, Adidas drop; Shell gains
CIA apologizes for spying on Senate staffers
Ebola crisis in Africa deepens

Focus on the economy
Small businesses add workers for 10th month
Chicago PMI plunges in biggest drop since 2008
Jobless claims rise one week after 14-year low
Employment cost index increases

Marijuana activist claims responsibility for Brooklyn Bridge’s white flags 
Who raised those white flags in Brooklyn?
Rev. Bud Green, who claims responsibility for the white flags over the Brooklyn Bridge, is one motivated stoner.
Colorado rollout of legal marijuana a success

This marijuana stock is 900% higher and
still smoking
Opinion: Cannabis Sativa CEO Gary Johnson says the potential for his company’s products is “staggering,” writes Philip van Doorn.

What to watch for in GoPro earnings
What to watch for in GoPro earnings
Camera-maker will publish its first quarterly earnings since it went public after the close on Thursday.

What to watch for in Tesla’s earnings
Tesla earnings: Look for factory news
Tesla Motors will report second-quarter earnings after the market closes.
What could bring down Tesla shares this week
Driverless cars set to hit U.K. roads

Argentina effectively in default
Argentina effectively in default
A trustee in charge of some of Argentina's debt says a payment had not been made on the bonds, effectively putting the country in default.
Argentine stocks plunge after default
Does your mutual fund own Argentina’s bonds?
Emerging market ETFs still have a lot to show
Did you miss this boom in foreign stocks?

Train your doctors to treat you right
Train your doctors to treat you right
As people get older, they’re more likely to see multiple doctors—and often, those doctors don’t communicate enough with each other.

Paul Merriman: Not all Vanguard funds are created equal
Not all Vanguard funds are equal
RetireMentors: Vanguard’s Small Cap Value Index is an excellent fund but there’s an even better choice in the Vanguard suite, says Paul Merriman.
Beware side effects from a target fund cure-all

What to expect from Expedia earnings
Can Expedia beat views again?
What to look for when the online travel company reports earnings after the close.
What to look for in LinkedIn earnings

World's unluckiest poker play out $1 million
World’s unluckiest poker player out $1 million
If you've ever missed out on a pot because your three-of-a-kind lost to a gut-shot straight at the river, Connor Drinan is playing a tiny violin for you.
Johnny Dronehunter, a shotgun-toting hero
Watch UCLA campus flood

When to claim Social Security
RetireMentors: An educated guess at longevity will help determine when to file for benefits, says Jeffrey B. Miller.
Social Security is in crisis
'Set it and forget it' retirement plans

August doesn’t deserve its bad reputation
Commentary: Mark Hulbert says even the market pros get this one wrong.
/conga/frontpage.html 315616
Don’t expect much, says Bill Gross
Bill Gross explains why investors need to lower their expectations for capital gains over the coming years.

10 small byut snobby cities
10 small but snobby cities
Website ranks these cities as the snobbiest based on the highest median household income and home values, plus the number of art galleries and private schools.
A city-by-city look at home prices in May
6 Californias? How about 7 Rhode Islands

Do pigs get more space on planes than you?
Already uncomfortable coach airline seats are getting smaller — so small that some pigs get more space in their cages than you do in coach.

How terrorist groups make their money
Kidnappings and illicit oil sales: How al Qaeda and the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant are bankrolling their operations.

Ruling on McDonald’s franchisees ignites firestorm
The National Labor Relations Board's ruling could cast a shadow across a wide variety of industries and companies that rely on franchise models.
McDonald’s ruling sets ominous tone
Yum: Shanghai Husi reports hit China chains
/conga/today.html 315617

Markets »

38.35MDow Volume:
Avg Vol: 78.42M
Price Chg %Chg 1 Day
Range: 1 Day
  • 1 Day
  • 5 Days
  • 1 Month
  • 3 Months
  • 6 Months
  • 1 Year
  • 2 Years
/quotes/zigman/627449/realtime 16,662 -218 1.29%
/quotes/zigman/12633936/realtime 4,388 -75 1.69%
S&P 500
/quotes/zigman/3870025/realtime 1,941 -29 1.48%
/quotes/zigman/629063/realtime 2,585 -34 1.30%
/quotes/zigman/635641/delayed 1,284 -13 0.98%
/quotes/zigman/2196854/delayed 98.35 -1.92 1.91%
FTSE 100
/quotes/zigman/3173262/delayed 6,730 -43 0.64%
/quotes/zigman/2380246/delayed 9,407 -186 1.94%
CAC 40
/quotes/zigman/3173214/delayed 4,246 -66 1.53%
/quotes/zigman/1482176/delayed 20,571 -317 1.52%
/quotes/zigman/2759620/delayed 10,707 -230 2.10%
Stoxx 600
/quotes/zigman/2380150/delayed 336 -4 1.31%
Asia Dow
/quotes/zigman/6959860/realtime 3,312 -21 0.64%
Nikkei 225
/quotes/zigman/5986735/delayed 15,621 -25 0.16%
Hang Seng
/quotes/zigman/2622475/delayed 24,757 +25 0.10%
/quotes/zigman/1859015/delayed 2,202 +20 0.93%
/quotes/zigman/1652085/delayed 25,895 -192 0.74%
/quotes/zigman/1709939/delayed 3,374 +20 0.61%
/quotes/zigman/4867933/realtime/sampled 1.34 0.00 0.06%
/quotes/zigman/4868099/realtime/sampled 102.81 +0.02 0.02%
/quotes/zigman/4867886/realtime/sampled 1.69 0.00 0.14%
/quotes/zigman/4867876/realtime/sampled 0.93 0.00 0.32%
DXY Index
/quotes/zigman/1652083/delayed 81.46 +0.06 0.07%
WSJ $ Idx
/quotes/zigman/9625991/realtime 73.90 +0.08 0.11%
U.S. 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866666/realtime 2.55 -0.01 0.21%
German 10y
/quotes/zigman/15866409/realtime 1.16 -0.01 1.28%
Italy 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866497/realtime 2.58 +0.01 0.28%
Spain 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866444/realtime 2.51 +0.02 0.99%
U.K. 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866328/realtime 2.60 0.00 0.00%
Japan 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866525/realtime 0.54 +0.01 1.09%
Crude Oil
98 -2 1.91%
1,284 -13 0.98%
/quotes/zigman/3098927/delayed 368 -4 1.08%
/quotes/zigman/21588489/delayed 16,609 -212 1.26%
/quotes/zigman/20258909/delayed 1,937 -28 1.44%
/quotes/zigman/12294966/delayed 20 0 0.67%

Markets News

  1. 48 min ago

    Shell’s gain curbs FTSE 100 losses

  2. 49 min ago

    Newscast: Argentina, U.S. wages help sink stocks

  3. 53 min ago

    European banks, Adidas drop; Shell gains

  4. 11:56 a.m.

    Treasurys swing higher amid investor jitters

  5. 11:55 a.m.

    Disappointing earnings, weak inflation hit European stocks

  6. 11:19 a.m.

    U.S. stocks slide on worries about Fed rate policy

  7. 11:19 a.m.

    Argentine stocks plunge after default

  8. 11:10 a.m.

    Yelp, 3D Systems stand out as tech stocks slump

  9. 11:08 a.m.

    Yum, Whole Foods sink on tepid earnings; Avon defies bad results

  10. 10:53 a.m.

    NRG buys $35 million in FuelCell Energy stock

  11. 10:51 a.m.

    Market bears fire shot across the bow

  12. 10:43 a.m.

    Natural gas supplies rise less than expected

  13. 10:35 a.m.

    What to look for in LinkedIn earnings

  14. 10:34 a.m.

    What to watch for in Tesla’s earnings

  15. 9:59 a.m.

    Yelp, 3D Systems lead broad slate of tech losses


Symbol Price Change % Change
FB /quotes/nls/fb 73.21 -1.47 -1.96%
AAPL /quotes/nls/aapl 95.84 -2.31 -2.35%
GOOG /quotes/nls/goog 574.55 -12.87 -2.19%
BAC /quotes/nls/bac 15.32 -0.26 -1.67%
C /quotes/nls/c 49.00 -0.99 -1.98%
F /quotes/nls/f 17.08 -0.38 -2.18%
T /quotes/nls/t 35.61 -0.75 -2.07%
BP /quotes/nls/bp 49.01 -0.53 -1.07%
GE /quotes/nls/ge 25.31 -0.33 -1.29%
Visit the quote page and your most recently viewed stocks will automatically be displayed here.
Please log in to view your watchlist

Rates »

5 yr CD
2 yr CD
1 yr CD
MMA $10K+
MMA $50K+

National averages from

You Don’t Need Another Credit Card, You Need A Better One.
Avg. APR Last Week 6 Months
Low Interest 10.37% 10.37% 10.46%
Balance Transfer 12.64% 12.64% 12.55%
Business 12.80% 12.80% 12.98%
Student 13.27% 13.27% 13.27%
Cash Back 14.91% 14.91% 14.62%
Reward 15.00% 15.00% 14.91%
Airline 15.46% 15.46% 14.51%
Bad Credit 22.73% 22.73% 22.73%
Instant Approval 28.00% 28.00% 28.00%
Trending Tickers
  • /quotes/nls/spy SPY-1.42%
  • /quotes/nls/yelp YELP-10.70%
  • /quotes/nls/gluu GLUU-16.96%
  • /quotes/zigman/3870025/realtime SPX-1.42%
  • /quotes/nls/s S-5.67%
  • /quotes/nls/tmus TMUS+7.63%
Powered by StockTwits
Link to MarketWatch's Slice.

As of July 2, 2013, the SmartMoney content you loved now lives on MarketWatch.

MarketWatch will continue to provide the same important news and information you rely on every day. And, as a MarketWatch user, you will be able to enjoy:

  • Personalized news and quote email alerts
  • Editorial e-newsletters about personal finance, mutual funds and market-specific coverage
  • Premium newsletters by our market experts
  • Games, such as Virtual Stock Exchange and Beat the Darts
  • Free registration

Email address


Forgot password?