Choosing the Best Health Plan

AS EMPLOYERS CONTINUE TO shift more of the financial burden to their employees, the cost of health care is projected to rise by 9% for the average worker from 2008 to 2009, according to benefits-consultant Hewitt Associates. If you're considering switching your health-insurance plan during open enrollment (which usually takes place in the fall), are starting a new job or are looking for insurance on your own, you'll want to compare how each plan stacks up. In addition to reviewing what will or won't be covered, you should have a sense of how much each option will cost you in out-of-pocket expenses.

The good news is that you're likely to have some choice over your plan. Approximately 30% of employers offer three medical plan options to their employees and another 28% of employers offer two options, according to 2007-2008 data from Hewitt Associates. Options include an HMO, a PPO (a preferred provider organization), a POS (point of service), an old-fashioned indemnity plan, and a traditional EPO (exclusive provider) plan. Our calculator can help you figure out which plan gives you the most bang for the buck. By entering the amount you paid in health-care costs last year and comparing it with the costs and reimbursement policies of the plans you're considering, you can see which plan makes the most sense — at least from your wallet's perspective.

But before you crunch the numbers, here are some tips on how to use this worksheet most effectively. First, if you're considering a PPO or POS plan — which provide a different reimbursement policy for doctors you see in-network vs. out — you should probably input the appropriate information for both situations in our calculator. (You can do so side-by-side, since our worksheet can handle two plans at once.) Typically, the way these policies work is that if you go to a doctor in-network, you'll pay a small dollar amount (known as a co-pay) somewhere in the vicinity of $20 per office visit. Should you go out-of-network, you'll be subject to coinsurance, which is usually 20% of the total bill after you've met the deductible.

You may also want to dig into your summary of benefits when estimating your health-care costs. This calculator assumes that the medical expenses you enter are reimbursable — and, unfortunately, that's not always the case. Physical therapy or mental-health sessions, for example, may be restricted to a certain number of visits annually. So make sure you read all the fine print before you make your final decision. Your actual out-of-pocket expenses could also be significantly greater than our calculator's estimation if the health plan rejects a claim or asks you to cover any amount above what the plan deems reasonable or customary.

And keep in mind that price isn't everything. When comparing an HMO with a PPO, the strict managed-care plan will always be more wallet-friendly. But often times you get what you pay for. So you may opt to spend a little more out of pocket for the freedom to see the doctor of your choice.

What Will That Health Plan Really Cost You?

Calculator - Compare Health Care Plan Costs -
Investor Alert

New York Markets Open in:

Futures: /quotes/zigman/20258906/realtime S&P 500 +0.3% /quotes/zigman/17899764/realtime DOW +0.2% /quotes/zigman/14529417/realtime NASDAQ +1.5%

Nasdaq futures soar on Apple; more earnings loom


• Earnings Wall:

Retirement: Getting by on $1 million may be tricky
 GS Photography/
A $1 million nest egg translates to around $40,000 a year in income: Could you make that work?
Do you have enough money to retire?
Retiring on under $25,000 a year

Retire Here, Not There: The high vistas of Colorado
Retire Here, Not There: Colorado Shutterstock
Reasonable tax rates and affordable housing help lure retirees seeking an active lifestyle.

Instead of taking kids to work, bring work to kids
Instead of taking kids to work, bring work to kids l i g h t p o e t /
Commentary: What's happened to vocational education, asksDiana Furchtgott-Roth.
Is take-kids-to-work day just a giant play date?

Why Boeing is liking 2014: Taxes, airlines and Putin
Workers assemble a Boeing Co. 787 Dreamliner airplane at the Boeing Everett Factory in Everett, Washington, U.S., on Wednesday, May 29, 2013. Boeing Co., rebounding from the 787 Dreamliner?s three-month grounding, is moving closer to a further production increase that would reward investors by freeing up billions of dollars for dividends and buybacks. Photographer: Patrick T. Fallon/BloombergHOLD EMBARGO UNTIL Friday, June 14th 2 a.m. Pacific***Workers assemble a Boeing 787 Dreamliner airplane on the production line at the Boeing Everett Factory in Everett, Washington, U.S., on Wednesday, May 29, 2013. Photographer: Patrick T. Fallon/Bloomberg Bloomberg
Boeing raises its full-year earnings outlook. Three key reasons: taxes, airlines and Vladimir Putin.

7 cars later, how ‘Tesla Jens’ earns his nickname
Nobody puts his krone where his mouth is like Norwegian ophthalmologist Jens Kratholm.
When celebrities, Twitter don’t mix
McDonald’s: Ronald McDonald will join Twitter
Aetna raises outlook after quarterly growth
Microsoft earnings: First go-round for new CEO
Time Warner Cable profit jumps 19%

Need to know
Stocks to watch: Apple, Amazon, Starbucks
GE in talks to buy Alstom for $13 billion: report
Is recovery in business investment 'durable'?
Putin warns as Ukraine moves in on separatists
Three Americans killed in Afghan shooting
E-cigarettes face first regulations: WSJ
FTSE at 7-week high |
European stocks strong
Euro shakes off Draghi warning over currency
Draghi warns of strong euro; may trigger easing
Meet me on the court, Republican tells Obama

Russia warns Ukraine not to act
As Kiev resumes its clampdown on activists, Kremlin minister says action will be considered an attack on Russia itself.
Ukraine army enters pro-Russian city: AFP
U.S. troops arrive in Poland

U.S. troops sent near Russia as tensions build

Mobile, the cloud key to Microsoft earnings
Satya Nadella steps up for his first results as CEO. Here's what to expect in the software maker's third-quarter report.
Facebook profit rises on ad-sales surge

Coke holds to pay plan; Buffett bows out
It's hard to see how David Winters could force Coca-Cola to give up its 2014 executive equity plan. In the end, he didn't.

Bentley teases SUV for 2016
The auto maker has revealed a sneak peek of its coming SUV, setting a date to go on sale.
VW hires former Audi leader for Bugatti, Bentley

10 reasons why Big Oil may drive a 2020 crash
Commentary: These early warnings signal a collapse by the end of the decade, maybe 50% as gas prices shoot up, writes Paul B. Farrell.
Lewis: Fed’s corrupt policies cost us big
China looks at Alibaba founder’s deal (Caixin)

Watch this iceberg six times size of Manhattan
Think of "a large sheet cake floating through the Southern Ocean."
‘Game of Thrones’ meets Google in Westeros
Google Street View adds time-machine feature

Sneak peek at new-look MarketWatch story pages
We're now offering a universal Android app along with our new iOS apps — and soon all of our article pages will be fully mobile optimized.
/conga/frontpage.html 305003

Small Business Benefits »
Secret weapon in the talent war
Employees care about money, but the right menu of other benefits can help small businesses hold on to their most valuable workers in a competitive marketplace.  | Small Business Benefits: Full report
/conga/panels/small-business.html 303944
Smarter Money Trading Deck
7 secrets for getting the best airline seat
Travel experts' tips on what to do to snag a better seat assignment without spending more.
Free one-way flight could cost 50,000 miles

How to teach your kids to be financially independent
How to teach your kids to be financially independent
At 14, continue to provide what your child needs, not everything she wants.

10 states with the worst bang for taxpayer bucks
10 states where taxpayers get worst bang for the buck
People living in these states don’t get great services for the money they pay in taxes.
10 states with best payoff for taxpayers
Anthony Mirhaydari: A currency war is coming Anthony Mirhaydari
A currency war
is coming
Thomas Kee: Is Apple good for traders, bad for investors? Thomas H. Kee
Apple is only good
for traders
Cody Willard: How to find off-the-radar stocks Cody Willard
How to find off-the-radar stocks
John Nyaradi: Oil and gas heat up John Nyaradi
Oil and gas heat up
David Waring: U.S. corporate bonds outperform junk David Waring
U.S. corporate bonds outperform junk
Is Netflix forming a head-and-shoulders?
6 melt-ups no one is talking about
More investing ideas and insights
/conga/frontpage_2.html 304994
Inside MarketWatch »

Where the smart money is
Commentary: The S&P 500 has ridden its long winning streak to a critical point, says Todd
Hulbert: The most contrarian ETFs
ETF: Holding blue chips, but riding EM growth

Hotel Four Seasons Baku, Baku, Azerbaijan
Some Four Seasons hotels look like this
Others look like the inside of a Boeing 757 — because that's precisely where they are (24/7 Wall St.)
10 things all-inclusive vacations won’t tell you
Las Vegas’s big bet on gay tourism

Puerto Rico woos rich with hefty tax breaks
Hedge-fund titan John Paulson is expected to invest $1 billion in the island by 2015 as it becomes a tax haven.
Retire overseas on less than $25,000 a year
Million-dollar homes selling well in U.S.

Two ways to play Einhorn’s tech bubble
Hedge-fund notable conmpares current situation with the tech bubble of the late 1990s (Minyanville).
Einhorn has down quarter, warns of bubble

/conga/today.html 305001

Retirement »
7 worst 401(k) mistakes
To reach the retirement you want, don't act like the typical 401(k) investor. Don't ignore fees and investments, don't fail to contribute up to your employer's match, and do think about your expenses.
/conga/panels/retirement.html 302646

MarketWatch Radio Network »

The Wall-Ye V.I.N. robot being used at a vineyard. AFP/Getty Images

Farmers embrace robots

Farmers are starting to use robots to milk their dairy herds, giving life on the farm has a new look.
/conga/panels/radio.html 304934

Markets »

76.83MDow Volume:
Avg Vol: 100.66M
Price Chg %Chg 1 Day
Range: 1 Day
  • 1 Day
  • 5 Days
  • 1 Month
  • 3 Months
  • 6 Months
  • 1 Year
  • 2 Years
/quotes/zigman/627449/realtime 16,502 -13 0.08%
/quotes/zigman/12633936/realtime 4,127 -34 0.83%
S&P 500
/quotes/zigman/3870025/realtime 1,875 -4 0.22%
/quotes/zigman/629063/realtime 2,516 +2 0.07%
/quotes/zigman/698029/realtime 1,271 -14 1.05%
/quotes/zigman/2237082/realtime 101.78 +0.34 0.34%
FTSE 100
/quotes/zigman/3173262/realtime 6,718 +43 0.64%
/quotes/zigman/2380246/realtime 9,564 +19 0.20%
CAC 40
/quotes/zigman/3173214/realtime 4,488 +36 0.82%
/quotes/zigman/1482176/realtime 21,807 +131 0.61%
/quotes/zigman/2759620/realtime 10,459 +35 0.34%
Stoxx 600
/quotes/zigman/2380150/realtime 337 +2 0.48%
Asia Dow
/quotes/zigman/6959860/realtime 3,101 -7 0.23%
Nikkei 225
/quotes/zigman/5986735/realtime 14,405 -141 0.97%
Hang Seng
/quotes/zigman/2622475/realtime 22,563 +53 0.24%
/quotes/zigman/1859015/realtime 2,057 -10 0.50%
/quotes/zigman/1652085/realtime 22,877 +118 0.52%
/quotes/zigman/1709939/realtime 3,284 +26 0.80%
/quotes/zigman/4867933/realtime/sampled 1.38 +0.00 0.02%
/quotes/zigman/4868099/realtime/sampled 102.49 -0.05 0.05%
/quotes/zigman/4867886/realtime/sampled 1.68 +0.00 0.04%
/quotes/zigman/4867876/realtime/sampled 0.93 0.00 0.29%
DXY Index
/quotes/zigman/1652083/realtime 79.83 -0.03 0.04%
WSJ $ Idx
/quotes/zigman/9625991/realtime 73.10 -0.01 0.01%
U.S. 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866666/realtime 2.71 +0.01 0.34%
German 10y
/quotes/zigman/15866409/realtime 1.55 +0.02 1.28%
Italy 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866497/realtime 3.13 +0.04 1.36%
Spain 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866444/realtime 3.08 +0.03 1.00%
U.K. 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866328/realtime 2.71 +0.03 1.03%
Japan 10yr
/quotes/zigman/15866525/realtime 0.62 +0.00 0.67%
Crude Oil
102 +0 0.34%
1,271 -14 1.05%
/quotes/zigman/1769730/realtime 511 +2 0.34%
/quotes/zigman/17899764/realtime 16,487 +27 0.16%
/quotes/zigman/20258906/realtime 1,879 +6 0.33%
/quotes/zigman/698627/realtime 19 0 1.91%


Symbol Price Change % Change
FB /quotes/nls/fb 61.36 -1.67 -2.65%
AAPL /quotes/nls/aapl 524.75 -6.95 -1.31%
GOOG /quotes/nls/goog 526.94 -7.87 -1.47%
BAC /quotes/nls/bac 16.37 0.08 0.49%
C /quotes/nls/c 48.40 0.38 0.79%
F /quotes/nls/f 16.23 0.13 0.81%
T /quotes/nls/t 34.92 -1.37 -3.78%
BP /quotes/nls/bp 48.81 -0.23 -0.47%
GE /quotes/nls/ge 26.42 -0.16 -0.60%
Visit the quote page and your most recently viewed stocks will automatically be displayed here.
Please log in to view your watchlist

Rates »

5 yr CD
2 yr CD
1 yr CD
MMA $10K+
MMA $50K+

National averages from

You Don’t Need Another Credit Card, You Need A Better One.
Avg. APR Last Week 6 Months
Low Interest 10.37% 10.37% 10.46%
Balance Transfer 12.64% 12.64% 12.49%
Business 12.80% 12.80% 12.98%
Student 13.27% 13.27% 13.27%
Cash Back 14.84% 14.84% 14.62%
Reward 14.96% 14.96% 14.87%
Airline 15.30% 15.30% 14.51%
Bad Credit 22.73% 22.73% 23.48%
Instant Approval 28.00% 28.00% 28.00%
Trending on Twitter
  • /quotes/nls/aapl AAPL-1.31%
  • /quotes/nls/fb FB-2.65%
  • /quotes/nls/cake CAKE-2.50%
  • /quotes/nls/crox CROX+1.42%
  • /quotes/nls/usd USD-0.23%
Powered by
Link to MarketWatch's Slice.

As of July 2, 2013, the SmartMoney content you loved now lives on MarketWatch.

MarketWatch will continue to provide the same important news and information you rely on every day. And, as a MarketWatch user, you will be able to enjoy:

  • Personalized news and quote email alerts
  • Editorial e-newsletters about personal finance, mutual funds and market-specific coverage
  • Premium newsletters by our market experts
  • Games, such as Virtual Stock Exchange and Beat the Darts
  • Free registration

Email address


Forgot password?